Get Your Pie On with These Recipes for 45 Perfect Low-Carb Pies and Extras!
A slice of pie brings comfort like nothing else. For me, a perfect pie recalls afternoons with my grandmother, her coconut cream pie and berry pies fresh from the garden. I remember picking wild berries with her and learning how to press and flute the crust, how she mixed the filling, and how she would dot it with butter before baking. Those pies were simple, warm, and always perfect.
These low-carb pies capture that same nostalgic perfection—without added sugar. With the growing availability of natural low-carb sweeteners, you can enjoy pies that taste indulgent while keeping carbohydrates low. Popular choices include erythritol, liquid stevia, stevia glycerite, Sukrin 1:1, Sukrin Melis, Swerve (granulated or confection), and monk fruit sweetener. Some are available in stores and others online. They cost more than table sugar, but blending a bulk erythritol-style sweetener with a concentrated option like stevia extends the product and improves shelf life.
Enjoy baking again and treat yourself to some truly satisfying low-carb pies!
Easy Low-Carb Pie Crusts
Low-carb pie crusts often rely on ground nuts or seeds combined with butter or coconut oil. Adding ingredients such as protein isolate, unsweetened coconut, ground golden flax, gluten-free baking mix, or oat fiber can enhance texture and flavor while improving performance. These crusts are naturally gluten-free and pair well with any low-carb filling.
Almond Coconut Tart Crust – Low Carb Maven
Basic Low-Carb Almond Pie Crust – Low Carb Maven
Basic Shortbread Crust – Low Carb Maven
Coconut Flour Pie Crust – Sugar Free Mom
Low-Carb Walnut Pie Crust – Low Carb Maven
Low-Carb Nut-Free Grain-Free Chocolate Pie Crust – Sugar Free Mom
Multipurpose Keto Pie Crust – Keto Diet App
Peanut Flour Pie Crust – Low Carb Maven
Sweet Keto Pie Crust – Keto Diet App
Low-Carb Cream Pies
Low-carb cream pies usually begin with a pudding-style base folded into whipped cream, or by combining whipped cream with cream cheese or yogurt. The result is a light, silky filling that’s easy to make and reliably delicious—classic comfort with fewer carbs.
Banana Cream Pie – Maria Mind Body Health
Chocolate Cream Pie – Sugar Free Mom
Low-Carb Banana Cream Pie – Low Carb Maven
Low-Carb Lemon Curd Pie – Low Carb Maven
Low-Carb Strawberry Cream Pie – Low Carb Maven
Low-Carb Peanut Butter Pie – Low Carb Maven
Sugar-Free Coconut Cream Pie – Low Carb Yum
Sugar-Free Grasshopper Mousse Pie – Sugar Free Mom
Sugar-Free Lemon Cream Pie – Sugar Free Mom
Low-Carb Meringue Pies
Meringues and marshmallow-like toppings can be challenging when you replace sugar, because sugar contributes structure and shine. Still, some recipes successfully use low-carb sweeteners to produce glossy, stable meringues and delightful results.
Lemon Meringue Pie – Ditch The Carbs
Lemon Meringue Pie – All Day I Dream About Food
Low-Carb Raspberry Meringue Pie – Keto Diet App
Strawberry Rhubarb Meringue Pie Bars – I Breathe I’m Hungry
Low-Carb Layered Desserts
Layered desserts feed a crowd and make a striking centerpiece for potlucks and family gatherings. These low-carb takes preserve the rich layers and textures of the originals while swapping in sugar-free and low-carb ingredients that still impress.
Coconut Cream Layered Dream – Low Carb Maven
Low-Carb Chocolate Lasagna – Low Carb Maven
Low-Carb Peanut Butter Layered Dream – Low Carb Maven
No-Bake Banana Split Cake Cheesecake – Low Carb Yum
Low-Carb Fruit Pies
Using fresh fruit in low-carb desserts is a balancing act: you want bright fruit flavor without excess carbohydrates. These recipes use clever techniques and ingredient swaps to let fruit shine while keeping carbs in check.
Chayote Squash Mock Apple Pie – Low Carb Yum
Strawberry Hand Pies – All Day I Dream About Food
Low-Carb Banoffee Pie – Low Carb So Simple
Low-Carb Cheesecake Pies
Cheesecake pies are timeless favorites, and low-carb versions deliver the same creamy satisfaction. Whether baked, crustless, or no-bake, these sugar-free cheesecake pies are simple to prepare and always crowd-pleasers.
Nana’s Cheese Pie – Low Carb Maven
No-Bake Blueberry Cheesecake Pie – All Day I Dream About Food
Sweet Ricotta Cheese Pie – Low Carb Yum
Low-Carb Key Lime Pies
Key lime pie is loved for its tangy, custard-like texture. These low-carb adaptations maintain that creamy, bright flavor while replacing traditional sugar with low-carb alternatives for a lighter carb count.
Coconut Key Lime Pie – The Nourished Caveman
Sugar-Free Key Lime Pie – Maria Mind Body Health
Low-Carb Chocolate Pies
Chocolate pies are universally adored—mousse, French silk, pudding, or cream. These low-carb chocolate pies deliver deep, satisfying chocolate flavor without the sugar, perfect for sharing with family or guests.
Brownie Truffle Pie – All Day I Dream About Food
Chocolate Coconut Mounds Pie – Sugar Free Mom
Dark Chocolate Mousse Pie – Low Carb Yum
French Silk Pie – Maria Mind Body Health
Low-Carb French Silk Pie – Low Carb Maven
Low-Carb Grasshopper Pie – I Breathe I’m Hungry
Extras
Finishing touches elevate a dessert. From billowy whipped cream or whipped coconut cream to sugar-free caramel or hot fudge, these extras add polish and flavor without excess sugar—small touches that deliver big “wow” moments.
Homemade Low-Carb Caramel Sauce – Low Carb Maven
Best Low-Carb Caramel Sauce – All Day I Dream About Food
Low-Carb Hot Fudge Sauce – Low Carb Maven
Sugar-Free Chocolate Syrup – Low Carb Yum
How to Make Whipped Cream – Food.com
How to Make Whipped Coconut Cream – Low Carb Maven (video)
*This post previously included affiliate links to products the author uses; links supported the site at no extra cost to readers.